Visual Abstract
Abstract
Fructose metabolism has been implicated in various diseases, including metabolic disorders, neurodegenerative disorders, cardiac disorders, and cancer. However, the limited availability of a quantitative imaging radiotracer has hindered its exploration in pathology and diagnostic imaging. Methods: We adopted a molecular design strategy based on the catalytic mechanism of aldolase, a key enzyme in fructolysis. We successfully synthesized a radiodeoxyfluorinated fructose analog, [18F]4-fluoro-4-deoxyfructose ([18F]4-FDF), in high molar activity. Results: Through heavy isotope tracing by mass spectrometry, we demonstrated that C4-deoxyfluorination of fructose led to effective trapping as fluorodeoxysorbitol and fluorodeoxyfructose-1-phosphate in vitro, unlike C1- and C6-fluorinated analogs that resulted in fluorolactate accumulation. This observation was consistent in vivo, where [18F]6-fluoro-6-deoxyfructose displayed substantial bone uptake due to metabolic processing whereas [18F]4-FDF did not. Importantly, [18F]4-FDF exhibited low uptake in healthy brain and heart tissues, known for their high glycolytic activity and background levels of [18F]FDG uptake. [18F]4-FDF PET/CT allowed for sensitive mapping of neuro- and cardioinflammatory responses to systemic lipopolysaccharide administration. Conclusion: Our study highlights the significance of aldolase-guided C4 radiodeoxyfluorination of fructose in enabling effective radiotracer trapping, overcoming limitations of C1 and C6 radioanalogs toward a clinically viable tool for imaging fructolysis in highly glycolytic tissues.
The use of fructose as an energy source (i.e., fructolysis) during the onset and progression of a variety of diseases is a continued area of both fundamental and clinical investigation, with inflammation-induced energy crises activating a fructolytic state in the affected tissues. In the heart, the switch from glycolysis to fructolysis has been identified in cardiac hypertrophy (1,2) and myocardial infarction (3), with data supporting a hypoxia-driven activation of this aberrant metabolic program. In the brain, fructolysis is thought to be a putative driver of Alzheimer disease (4) and has been shown to be proinflammatory, with negative implications after traumatic or stroke injury and in psychologic health (5). The switch from glucose to fructose as an energy source may also be a key oncologic driver, promoting the progression of a variety of solid tumors through the concerted transcriptional activation of transport and metabolic machinery (6–10). Excessive fructose consumption has also been associated with a liver-centered metabolic syndrome thought to drive obesity and diabetes (11) and to be a major player in the related cardiovascular (11,12), ocular (13), and degenerative (12) outcomes. The fundamental importance of fructolysis in a range of diseases has encouraged the development of methods to noninvasively map fructose metabolism, a challenge that is currently an unsolved problem.
Canonic fructose metabolism begins with glucose transporter 5–mediated transport into the cell and ketohexokinase-mediated trapping of the sugar as fructose-1-phosphate (Fig. 1A) (11). Phosphorylation is followed by carbon chain scission through the activity of aldolase enzymes and the subsequent formation of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate, which continues to be metabolized downstream. This metabolic cascade has been followed using noninvasive in vivo imaging in preclinical models, taking advantage of the spectroscopic capabilities of deuterium and hyperpolarized MRI (14,15). Toward the clinical translational use of fructolysis as a quantitative imaging biomarker, previous work has attempted to trace fructose metabolism by PET by installing radiofluorine (18F) at the C1 or C6 positions (16–20). The early metabolic trapping of fructose would lend itself to tracing of aberrant metabolism similarly to [18F]FDG, the most extensively applied PET nuclear diagnostic used in the clinic. However, the significant bone-derived radioactivity observed by PET from previous radiodeoxyfluorofructose analogs suggests that cellular trapping was not achieved (Fig. 1A).
To produce a radiofluorinated fructose analog that is trapped in cells as its phosphorylated metabolite, we closely examined the catalytic mechanism of aldolase, the enzyme for which fructose-1-phosphate is a substrate (Fig. 1B) (21). Within the aldolase active site, the initial Schiff base formation with the C2-carbonyl is immediately followed by a base-mediated proton abstraction from the C4-hydroxyl moiety to induce C–C bond scission. Given the critical role of the C4-OH in the catalytic mechanism, we hypothesized that the deoxyfluorination of the C4 position would prevent aldolase-mediated scission (Fig. 1C), resulting in the trapping of 4-fluoro-4-deoxyfructose (4-FDF) within the metabolic cell of origin (Fig. 1A). In the current work, we generated 4-FDF, evaluated its metabolic flux in vitro relative to 1-fluoro-1-deoxyfructose (1-FDF) and 6-fluoro-6-deoxyfructose (6-FDF), and compared the PET imaging of [18F]4-FDF with that of [18F]6-FDF and [18F]FDG in tracing metabolism in mouse models of cancer and systemic inflammation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Synthesis
All synthetic procedures are described in detail in the supplemental materials (available at http://jnm.snmjournals.org).
In Vitro Metabolic Tracing
All procedures for metabolic tracing of [U13C]-fructose analogs are provided in the supplemental materials.
Animal Models
All animal research was approved by the institutional animal care and use committee of the University of Ottawa under animal use protocols SCe-3254-R3 (tumor study) and SCe-4019-A1 (inflammation study). Mice were housed in standard cages, kept on a 12-h light–dark cycle, and provided standard rodent chow and water ad libitum.
Eight-week-old female nu/nu mice were inoculated, subcutaneously under the left shoulder, with 10 × 106 HepG2 cells suspended in 50% Matrigel (Corning)–50% Dulbecco modified Eagle medium. Within 3 wk of implantation, the mice were imaged by PET/CT.
Eight-week-old male C57BL/6 mice received a 5 mg/kg dose of lipopolysaccharide through intraperitoneal injection 24 h before planned PET/CT imaging. For 12 h after receiving the injection, they were kept warm, given fluids subcutaneously, monitored, and scored for severity of response to lipopolysaccharide as published previously (22).
PET/CT Imaging
PET/CT imaging was performed on an Si78PET/CT scanner with a 4-position hotel having adjustable isoflurane and respiratory monitoring for each position (Bruker USA). Tail veins were catheterized, and an anatomic CT scan was acquired over the whole of the mouse bodies using the rat settings. The PET acquisition was started just before a bolus intravenous injection of approximately 7.4 MBq of radiotracer. Dynamic scans were acquired in list mode over 45 min and sorted into sixteen 0.5-mm sinogram bins for image reconstruction (4 × 15 s, 4 × 60 s, and 8 × 300 s). Iterative reconstruction was performed using 3-dimensional ordered-subsets expectation maximization followed by fast maximum a posteriori estimation using Paravision 360 software, version 3.4 (Bruker). Four-mouse images were split into individual mice, and the bed was removed using PMOD (Bruker). VivoQuant, version 2022 (InviCRO), was used to visualize tissue uptake, for definition of 3-dimensional volumes of interest, and to visualize in 3 dimensions for volume rendering. The count densities were averaged for all volumes of interest at each time point to obtain a time–activity curve. Tumor and tissue time–activity curves were normalized to injected dose, measured by a CRC-15 PET dose calibrator (Capintec, Inc.), and expressed as percentage injected dose per cubic centimeter of tissue.
Statistical Analyses
Statistical analyses were performed using Prism (version 9.5.0; GraphPad, Inc.). Comparisons across more than 2 groups were performed by 1-way ANOVA followed by the Tukey test for honestly significant differences. Normality was assumed when appropriate for all datasets. Before ANOVA, the Levene test was used to confirm equal variance, and visual quantile–quantile plot analysis was used to confirm homoscedasticity.
RESULTS
To characterize the structure–activity effect of fructose deoxyfluorination on metabolic flux, we evaluated the metabolism of isotopically labeled [U13C]-fructose and of [U13C]-1-FDF, [U13C]-6-FDF, and [U13C]-4-FDF deoxyfluorinated fructose analogs in vitro in HepG2 human hepatocarcinoma cells by mass spectrometry (Fig. 2). HepG2 was chosen as a model cell line because of a recent report by Tee et al. outlining its propensity for fructolysis (23). [U13C]-1-FDF and [U13C]-6-FDF were synthesized according to previously published methods (16,17), and [U13C]-4-FDF was synthesized as described in the supplemental materials. After confirming that [U13C]-fructose was metabolized as expected through both fructolytic and polyol pathways to establish a baseline for tracing fructose metabolism (Fig. 2A), we next examined the relative flux of the deoxyfluorinated analogs (Fig. 2B). [U13C]-1-FDF showed limited metabolism through the polyol pathway, with most of the 13C-labeled cellular product being [U13C]-deoxyfluorolactate (Fig. 2B). Of critical importance, however, is that although [U13C]-6-FDF metabolism produced a substantial amount of [U13C]-deoxyfluorolactate through scission and downstream metabolism (Fig. 2B), [U13C]-4-FDF metabolism halted at [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxy-1-phosphate, the fructolytic metabolite that is the substrate for aldolase-mediated scission (Fig. 2B). Uniquely, [U13C]-4-FDF metabolism also resulted in the accumulation of [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxyfructose-1,6-bisphophate. A key outcome of this experiment was the confirmation that all deoxyfluorinated analogs of fructose entered the cells rapidly (within 30 min). To validate the observed metabolite trapping, a time course evaluation of [U13C]-4-FDF metabolism was performed over 60 min, demonstrating the steady-state accumulation of [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxyfructose-1-phosphate and [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxyfructose-1,6-bisphosphate and the increase in [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxysorbitol throughout the 60 min of incubation (Fig. 2C). The results of this study support our hypothesis that, like native fructose (Fig. 2D), neither [U13C]-1-FDF (Fig. 2E) nor [U13C]-6-FDF is metabolically trapped (Fig. 2G) but that the deoxyfluorination of fructose at C4 prevents aldolase-mediated hexose scission and traps the deoxyfluorinated fructose analog in the cell (Fig. 2F). By rethinking the site of deoxyfluorination to afford metabolic trapping as informed by the catalytic mechanism of the enzyme immediately ensuing to the intended trapped metabolite, we uncovered the chemical requirements for mapping fructolysis.
To proceed toward fructolysis mapping in vivo by PET, a radiodeoxyfluorination approach was designed to afford nucleophilic substitution at the C4 position using standard radiochemical techniques somewhat related to the routine production of [18F]FDG. Details of the synthesis of compounds 1–4 have been reported previously (24), and further synthetic steps and chemical characterization for compounds 5, 6, and [18F]4-FDF are provided in the supplemental materials (Supplemental Schemes 1–5; Supplemental Figs. 3–232). The precursor synthesis began with C1-OH methylation and dimethyl ketalation of C2-OH and C3-OH, followed by the protection of C6-OH with chloromethyl methyl ether in order to isolate the C4-OH (Fig. 3A). The stereochemistry at C4 was then inverted in 2 steps and was converted to the tosylated precursor 5 (Fig. 3A). The C4 stereoinversion was necessary to allow the subsequent radiodeoxyfluorination step to restore the C4-d-enantiomer after the [18F]tetraethylammonium fluoride–mediated nucleophilic attack (Fig. 3B, 6). Rapid on-module deprotection resulted in [18F]4-FDF in good radiochemical yield (25%–30%) and molar activity (25.3 ± 0.6 GBq/nmol) comparable to that resulting from the routine production of [18F]FDG (25).
With the confirmation of cell uptake and intracellular trapping of [U13C]4-FDF, and the successful production of the radiofluorinated analog, the biodistribution of [18F]4-FDF was evaluated in a heterotopic HepG2 xenograft mouse model and compared with the biodistribution of [18F]6-FDF and [18F]FDG (Fig. 4). [18F]1-FDF was not evaluated in vivo since it was already demonstrated to be poorly retained in cells in vitro and in vivo (18). After intravenous injection, [18F]4-FDF was found to accumulate in the tumor, with renal exceeding hepatobiliary excretion (Fig. 4A). This pattern of radiotracer retention was similarly observed for [18F]6-FDF, with a key difference, however, being bone uptake (Fig. 4B). Although any bone uptake was limited to less than 2% injected dose/mL for [18F]4-FDF (Fig. 4A; Supplemental Fig. 2), bone uptake was 3.69-fold higher (>7% injected dose/mL) after [18F]6-FDF imaging (Fig. 4B and 4D). This extensive bone uptake, which continues to increase over time (Supplemental Fig. 2), was reported previously for [18F]6-FDF (17) and is supported by the metabolic flux outcomes of [U13C]6-FDF demonstrating the production of [U13C]fluorodeoxylactate (Figs. 2B and 2G).
Overall, the accumulation of [18F]4-FDF in normal mouse tissues was lower than that of [18F]FDG (Figs. 4A vs. 4C). Notably, the area under the time–activity curve in the brain and heart was 6.01- and 5.29-fold greater, respectively, for [18F]FDG than for [18F]4-FDF (Fig. 4D), suggesting that healthy brain and heart have a limited dependence on fructolysis for energy production. To further investigate whether a fructolytic switch occurs in inflammatory neural and cardiac tissues, as previously proposed (1–5,12), a mouse model of systemic inflammation was examined (Fig. 5). Mice receiving saline vehicle (Fig. 5A) or intraperitoneal bacterial cell wall lipopolysaccharide, as previously described (Fig. 5B) (22), were imaged by [18F]4-FDF PET/CT 24 h after injection. A significant increase in cardiac (Figs. 5D and 5F) and brain (Figs. 5C and 5F) uptake of [18F]4-FDF was observed after lipopolysaccharide treatment in all mice evaluated. Both the brain and the heart demonstrated inflammatory responses to lipopolysaccharide stimulation within 24 h of its systemic introduction, mediated through toll-like receptor engagement on microglia or cardiac adrenergic cells (26,27). The low uptake of [18F]4-FDF in healthy brain and heart contributed to an increased signal-to-noise ratio for the mapping of cardio- and neuroinflammation (Figs. 5C and 5D).
DISCUSSION
Although the pathologic switch to fructose metabolism has been implicated in a variety of metabolic, neurodegenerative, and cardiac diseases, as well as being a driver or consequence of malignancy, the evaluation of fructolysis in fundamental mechanisms of pathology and its implementation as a diagnostic imaging biomarker has been limited by the lack of a quantitative tracer for imaging-based analysis. Taking a molecular design approach informed by the catalytic mechanism of aldolase, the fructolytic enzyme whose activity must be blocked in order to afford metabolic trapping, we synthesized a radiodeoxyfluorinated analog of fructose: [18F]4-FDF. Radiosynthesis was realized on a standard radiofluorination module in good yield and molar activity, mimicking the nucleophilic radiofluorination and acid-catalyzed deprotection used for the preparation of [18F]FDG (Fig. 3).
As compared with previously reported C1 and C6 radioanalogs of fructose, using heavy-isotope tracing by mass spectrometry we demonstrated that the C4 deoxyfluorination of fructose led to trapping as fluorodeoxysorbitol and fluorodeoxyfructose-1-phosphate in vitro (Fig. 2). Key differences in polyol pathway flux were also observed between the different fluorinated positional isomers. The limited polyol flux observed for C1 fluorodeoxyfructose is likely the result of improper substrate positioning in the sorbitol dehydrogenase active site by the deoxyfluorination of C1, which prevents a critical C1-OH–to–zinc interaction (28). In contrast, both [U13C]-6-FDF and [U13C]-4-FDF were capable of proceeding through the polyol pathway but did not form detectable amounts of glucose-6-phosphate (Fig. 2B). The arrest at [U13C]-4/6-fluorodeoxysorbitol could be the result of the reduction of aldose reductase activity either through active-site water displacement or through catalytically detrimental interactions with the active-site–adjacent specificity pocket (29,30). Notably, neither the C1- nor the C6-fluorinated analog led to trapping, but rather there was a procession through fructolysis to produce fluorolactate. This result was recapitulated in vivo, with [18F]6-FDF showing significant bone uptake that was a result of metabolic processing but was not observed using [18F]4-FDF (Fig. 4).
Our metabolic tracing studies suggest that the bone uptake observed with [18F]6-FDF imaging in vivo (Fig. 4) may be the result not of tumor cell–induced defluorination but of lactate formation (Fig. 2). Lactate is actively pumped out of tumor cells by influx–efflux monocarboxylate transporters 1 and 4, which contribute to the acidic tumor microenvironment that is a hallmark of solid tumors (31,32). The direct mechanism of radiofluorinated metabolite uptake by bone remains to be uncovered; however, it is known that osteoblasts express monocarboxylate transporter 1 and actively take up lactate (33–35). Additionally, extratumoral metabolism may also contribute to radioactivity uptake in the bone, as hepatic lactate metabolism through lactate dehydrogenase can produce pyruvate with a potential for defluorination (36). By any mechanism, both in vitro and in vivo data demonstrate that radiodeoxyfluorination of fructose at C4, but not at C6, can subvert cellular radiometabolite loss and bone accumulation.
An important outcome of the stable tracing of fructolysis afforded by [18F]4-FDF was the observation of low uptake in healthy brain and heart (Fig. 5), tissues that are highly glycolytic and associated with high background levels of [18F]FDG uptake (Fig. 4). The low fructolytic background rates in these tissues afforded the sensitive mapping of the neuro- and cardioinflammatory response to systemic lipopolysaccharide administration by [18F]4-FDF (Fig. 5). Therefore, the aldolase-prescribed C4 radiodeoxyfluorination of fructose resulted in radiotracer trapping on intracellular uptake and phosphorylation (Fig. 1), overcoming limitations to fructolysis tracing by C1 and C6 radioanalogs.
Although [18F]FDG is used clinically to map glucose uptake for diagnostic imaging of traumatic brain injury (37), dementia (38), and Alzheimer disease (39), the estimation of neuroinflammation by [18F]FDG PET is difficult because physiologic glucose uptake may obscure inflammation-specific signal. The presence of inflammatory cells can mask metabolic deficits in neurodegenerative diseases, hindering the use of glucose consumption as a biomarker in these cases (40). Neuronal [18F]FDG uptake in a lipopolysaccharide-treated mouse therefore does not necessarily reflect metabolic state or neuronal damage, as microglial activation and immune cell infiltration confound uptake (41). [18F]FDG PET may also be used for diagnostic imaging of cardiopulmonary inflammation (42), cardiopulmonary infection (43), and atherosclerosis; however, efforts must be made to minimize myocardial glucose metabolism before imaging to reduce the false-positive rate due to the low signal-to-noise ratio (44,45). These efforts rely on a diet-based metabolic switch from glucose to free fatty acids, relying heavily on patient compliance. The low brain and heart uptake in healthy, nonfasting mice described here makes fructose metabolism an attractive biomarker in tissues that are otherwise highly glycolytic and have high [18F]FDG uptake in the absence of disease.
CONCLUSION
The metabolic flux of deoxyfluorofructose was characterized by heavy-isotope labeling. [U13C]-1-FDF exhibited limited polyol metabolism, whereas both [U13C]-6-FDF and [U13C]-4-FDF showed polyol pathway involvement. Only [U13C]-4-FDF metabolism halted at [U13C]-4-fluorodeoxyfructose-1-phosphate, supporting its unique ability to be trapped within cells. [18F]4-FDF was synthesized with good molar activity and radiochemical yield. In a HepG2 xenograft mouse model, [18F]4-FDF exhibited tumor accumulation with minimal bone uptake, whereas [18F]6-FDF displayed substantial bone retention. [18F]4-FDF displayed lower accumulation in normal mouse tissues than did [18F]FDG, notably in the brain and heart. As a result, a significant increase in [18F]4-FDF uptake in cardiac and brain tissues was observed after lipopolysaccharide treatment, highlighting the potential of [18F]4-FDF PET/CT for sensitive mapping of cardio- and neuroinflammation in highly glycolytic tissues. Overall, this research provides critical insights into the metabolic fate of deoxyfluorinated fructose analogs and demonstrates the potential of [18F]4-FDF for mapping disease or injury involving cardio- and neuroinflammation. With the ability to safely and effectively map fructolysis in mice, and low uptake in healthy tissues compared with [18F]FDG, [18F]4-FDF offers a clinically viable tool for diagnostic imaging of tissues with a high baseline glycolytic index. As dosimetry is not expected to be limiting, the clinical translation of this biosimilar radiotracer is feasible.
DISCLOSURE
Funding was received from NSERC (RGPIN-2021-03387, to Adam Shuhendler), the Canada Research Chairs Program (950-230754, to Adam Shuhendler), and the Canadian Cancer Society (grant 707503 to Christina Addison and Adam Shuhendler). Metabolites were analyzed at the University of Ottawa Metabolomics Core Facility. This facility is supported by the Terry Fox Foundation and Ottawa University. No other potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
KEY POINTS
QUESTION: Can fructose metabolism accurately be mapped by PET?
PERTINENT FINDINGS: By installation of radiofluorine at the C4 position of fructose, fructose metabolism can be accurately mapped because of intracellular trapping of the phosphorylated metabolite. Fructose use was low in the healthy brain and heart but elevated in disease, providing an opportunity for imaging neuro- and cardioinflammation.
IMPLICATIONS FOR PATIENT CARE: The introduction of [18F]4-FDF opens new doors for mapping inflammation in cardiac and neural diseases with a biosimilar radiotracer based on a modified dietary sugar.
Footnotes
Published online Jan. 25, 2024.
- © 2024 by the Society of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging.
REFERENCES
- Received for publication October 19, 2023.
- Accepted for publication December 6, 2023.